As most of you know, Grim's Hall has been without television since 2006 -- originally as a cost-saving measure, and later because we found we didn't miss it. I didn't have a lot of time for television before that, and one reason it made so little impact on us was that we were always too busy to watch it anyway. I mostly used it to watch old movies that happened to be on late in the evening as I was winding down for bed, but that can be done more cheaply in many ways. In addition I've often been out of the country, in places where television wasn't necessarily available or in English.
For these reasons I've been largely immune to many of the worst trends afflicting society these last twenty years: reality television, the general decline of standards of obscenity, the general rise of libertine standards on displays of sexuality. But I had thought I was more or less engaged with the news, because I keep up with the news carefully as a citizen ought to do.
These last few days have disabused me of that notion. Visiting a relative in the hospital, I've been exposed to television news as it is now done on both local and cable networks. I am appalled.
We used to watch the news at home when I was a boy, and I remember that it was nearly always bad. But I don't remember the obsessive focus on getting and displaying footage of those whom the overwhelming force of tragedy has momentarily turned to screaming, crying, emotional wrecks. At some point the news has become genuinely wicked, preying on disaster for the pure voyeuristic pleasure of seeing a human being reduced to an animal.
This is horrifying and shameful. I dread to consider what it says about our culture.
6 comments:
I've been away on business this week and I turned the hotel TV on twice, each time to check the local weather radar. I've come to detest the national and international TV news. Last Friday may have been the final straw. We didn't even get to see the local weather because the networks overrode the local broadcasters from 1810 local time to after 2130 (when I went to bed). And the fixation on the "disaster de jour" cannot be good for society.
LittleRed1
I usually refer to it as 'disaster porn', but really, it is a sort of psychological vampirism, feeding off the pain of others.
I contrast it with foreign news programs I have access to, via a local 'independent' station; one is the NHK, the Japanese national network, and that is about as sober, 'just the facts, ma'am' sort of reporting as you could ever imagine. Even their coverage of the Japanese Earthquake was restrained. Perhaps it just a reflection of the culture, where politeness is still valued. Another is a French production, which is fairly restrained, although it has 'round table' discussions that get fairly animated, but the tone is civil. The last is this Russian program, which may as well be Soviet, for all the heavy-handed rhetoric employed. It's almost funny. And, they regularly employ what I'd call 'leftist' US blogger-types. Sometimes it seems like parody.
All of them are preferable to any of the letter network shows. (I can't speak to cable, not being subscribed to it.)
All of them are preferable to any of the letter network shows. (I can't speak to cable, not being subscribed to it.)
Amen.
We let TV stop at the VCR/DVD player starting in '96 and have been the better for it. The younger ones still see some at friends on occasion, but for the most part, we are TV free. The kids can still climb trees, they are learning a bit about gardening (though most of that is either through exposure or against their desires. Heh.) And on occasion my better half and I can actually have a conversation.
Don't feel the need to "re-engage".
Life is Good.
William sends.
I watch sports on tv. (Go BRAVES!!!) For the relatively few other shows we like, I DVR so we can FFW through the crap we don't care to listen to or see.
I just wish I could do that on radio, too.
0>;~}
For years the only TV I watched were British comedies on PBS and sporting events. When the change to HDTV came, I found out that the amount of work I would need to do to get a remote functioning with the HDTV box wasn't worth it.
I stopped listening to TV network news decades ago. The commercials irritated me.
If I missed TV, I would take the time to program the remote correctly.
Post a Comment