The Winter Philosophy Project

As readers of the Hall know, I have in recent years spent the winter months writing a commentary on this-or-that work of philosophy. During the long nights and cold weather it can be a profitable way to pass the time until the world outside becomes more congenial. 

This year, instead of writing a commentary I think I will write an original work. I have one in mind that I have been thinking for a few years now that I ought to write. It should be an ethical and political philosophical work on the value of minding one's own business. 

There is a clear universal value here: everyone would be happier if other people minded their own business more than they do, accepted the individual's own sense of what was most important to them more than they do, and attempted to impose externally valued things upon them less than they do. 

However, the opposing view is endemic especially to political philosophy. Readers who have followed my commentary on Plato's Laws or Aristotle's EN -- or remarks from his Politics and Rhetoric likewise, though I haven't written commentaries on those -- know that the idea that the Wise should impose rules and structures to guide others towards virtue are at the basis of their projects. Collectivist philosophies of our own age draw generally from a chain that usually runs through Marx and Hegel back to Plato; but even many Christian thinkers, who reject at least Marxism's claim that religion is merely an opiate, generally think that institutions and laws should impose values on the people to morally guide them towards right living. Republicans generally want to ban pornography; Democrats want to ban guns, even when the guns are chiefly used for lawful purposes and to the common good; in both cases the chief objection seems to be that the things cause people to become morally worse and that we'd have a better society if we eliminated the poisons they represent. Neither of the major ethical traditions at work today, Utilitarianism nor Deontology, are interested in the question of minding one's own business; rather, they seek to shape society either to increase collective utility or morality.

Over against this massive set of traditions stands only a limited endorsement of rights like free speech and free association (both under assault) in the American tradition; or the more radical Stoic philosophers' claims that you should only attend to your own mind, and not really even your own body, since only that is under your control. Such a discipline would entail 'minding your business,' but the point wasn't that minding your business was a moral duty, rather that doing anything else was a waste of your limited time and attention. 

So I think I need to write this book while power and time remains to me to do it. I doubt anyone will agree with it, but that isn't the point of philosophy. The point is to try to say something that you think is true, and if  you succeed, to let other people explain their own reasons for disagreement. Philosophy is at its best when it creates problems like that for us to sharpen our minds by rubbing against. 

Dale’s Wheels Through Time Raffle

A record crowd for the raffle this year. 

Amidst all the natural treasures of Western North Carolina there is at least one man-made treasure, Dale’s Wheels Through Time motorcycle museum. Annually they hold a raffle of truly classic motorcycles to raise funds for the museum. This year the winner has his* choice of two: a 1946 Knucklehead or a 1938 Flathead. 

The big wooden spinner you can see in the picture had thousands of raffle tickets inside of it. After being spun by many volunteers, a five year old boy named Jack was asked to crawl inside to choose the winning ticket, as well as two smaller prizes. They use a five year old, they explained, because such are old enough to follow instructions but too young to accept bribes. 

I was there mostly to visit with an old Iraq War comrade who came down to attend the drawing. It was good to see an old friend, and to experience the pleasure he took in the beautiful mountains. 

* Women enter too, though sometimes on behalf of their husbands. The winner this year, Chuck, picked the Knucklehead. The third prize winner was among the gentlemen entered by their wives; I trust she will enjoy the prize also. 

Introduction to St. Basil's "Address to Young Men on the Right Use of Greek Literature,"

Grim has suggested we continue (ahem) with the study of St. Basil's "Address to Young Men on the Right Use of Greek Literature," where "Greek" is referring to the Greek pagan sages (philosophers, historians, poets, etc.). Given all the pagan literature we study here, I think it will be edifying reading.

I am only free for this on weekends right now, so we will work through the ten chapters over five or six weekends.

Icon of Solon, Aristotle, Plutarch, Thucydides, and Chilon in 
the monastery of St. Nikolaos Philanthropenoi

Occasionally one encounters icons of the pagan Greek sages in the narthexes or refectories of Orthodox churches or monasteries. These are outside the sanctuary and they are not shown with halos, but they are painted in the style of saints and within the church or monastery. For some, this is just bizarre: Why are pagans depicted in Christian churches and monasteries? That was my first thought. For others, this probably seems like heresy and / or blasphemy. But maybe St Basil can explain why studying the pagan sages is not only reasonable but also beneficial for Christians, and maybe especially for young men. We'll see.



St Basil the Great (ca. 330-379) was bishop of Caesarea in Cappadocia. He was from a wealthy family and educated in Greek literature as was normal at the time. One of his classmates was Julian (331-363), later emperor of Rome (r. 361-3) and an apostate who tried to restore paganism to the empire. St Basil is maybe best known among Orthodox laity for the liturgy that bears his name, used on Sundays during Lent, but he was a scholar and bishop who wrote and preached extensively in his day. He had a significant influence on thought in ancient Christianity.

Helpfully, he has given us an outline of his thoughts on the uses of Greek literature so that we can see an overview of where he will go with his topic. I will stop here today and let St Basil take over the rest of this post.

Address to Young Men on the Right Use of Greek Literature

Outline

I. Introduction: Out of the abundance of his experience the author will advise young men as to the pagan literature, showing them what to accept, and what to reject.

II. To the Christian the life eternal is the supreme goal, and the guide to this life is the Holy Scriptures; but since young men cannot appreciate the deep thoughts contained therein, they are to study the profane writings, in which truth appears as in a mirror.

III. Profane [i.e., secular, worldly] learning should ornament the mind, as foliage graces the fruit-bearing tree.

IV. In studying pagan lore one must discriminate between the helpful and the injurious, accepting the one, but closing one's ears to the siren song of the other.

V. Since the life to come is to be attained through virtue, chief attention must be paid to those passages in which virtue is praised; such may be found, for example, in Hesiod, Homer, Solon, Theognis, and Prodicus.

VI. Indeed, almost all eminent philosophers have extolled virtue. The words of such men should meet with more than mere theoretical acceptance, for one must try to realize them in his life, remembering that to seem to be good when one is not so is the height of injustice.

VII. But in the pagan literature virtue is lauded in deeds as well as in words, wherefore one should study those acts of noble men which coincide with the teachings of the Scriptures.

VIII. To return to the original thought, young men must distinguish between helpful and injurious knowledge, keeping clearly in mind the Christian's purpose in life. So, like the athlete or the musician, they must bend every energy to one task, the winning of the heavenly crown.

IX. This end is to be compassed by holding the body under, by scorning riches and fame, and by subordinating all else to virtue.

X. While this ideal will be matured later by the study of the Scriptures, it is at present to be fostered by the study of the pagan writers; from them should be stored up knowledge for the future.

Conclusion: The above are some of the more important precepts; others the writer will continue to explain from time to time, trusting that no young man will make the fatal error of disregarding them.

Quick - Before the Skipper Gets Back!

Everything back in it's place! Hide that! Raven! Gringo! Knock it off or it's the brig for the lot of us!



And a fun post from Sippican Cottage on covers, Not What I Expected.

Thanks raven & Gringo!

Now, ahem, let's finish up our discussion of St Basil's views on pagan literature ...

Punk as Heck

Saw that on a Jeep yesterday and am still chuckling about it. 

And raven found some more stuff at the bottom of that trunk:



A Reservation for the Bar

This Mexican restaurant is very crowded, but the bar was empty so I walked in and sat down. A minute later the manager came over and said, “Excuse me, sir, but you just walked past twenty-five people who were waiting and,” looked at me closely, “that’s not a problem for me, I’ll just tell them that you had a reservation.”

That’s all fine, I guess, but who ever heard of having to wait in line to sit at an empty bar? That’s not how bars work. If it’s busy I expect to wait at the bar; if the bar is full, I might expect to wait for a stool to open up. If you told me that some guy had made a reservation to sit at the bar I don’t know that I’d believe you. 

Arlington is a weird town. Flying in the morning, though, back to saner country. Been a productive trip, but I’m glad to be headed home. 

Hey! What's in this?

 


Setting course for Bakersfield!

Ack! How do you steer this blame thing!?

I have the conn, do I? Well, we're off for whisky before breakfast then, me lads & lasses! Ha!




We'll, uh, be sure to be back on course before the Cap'n returns. He'll never know. I promise.

Arlington

Arlington is not a fun town, but I don’t come here to have fun. I do meet some interesting people sometimes, including this time. 

Hopefully home Thursday. You have the conn, Mr. Doubting. 

Coonskin Cap


One line in this song about Davy Crockett mentions that he had 'a heavy axe to grind against Old Hickory,' the latter of course meaning Andrew Jackson. Now Jackson was a hickory that axes often broke against, including Crockett's. Crockett's opposition to Jackson's policies, especially the Indian Removal Act, led to the end of his Congressional career. Crockett had served under Jackson in the Tennessee militia during some of the wars with the Creek, and found that he preferred hunting game for the soldiers to killing Indians. That is not the worst thing to discover about yourself. A frontiersman might well have more in common with the Creek or the Cherokee than he did with the folks in Washington. His opposition to their forcible removal was part of an honorable discovery that, having fought them, he didn't hate them.

Just a few years later he took a band of volunteers and marched to Texas, where he died and came home to legend.

Great Smoky Mountains Railroad

They had an actual steam engine today. 




I don’t know how much of the work of pulling the train it was doing. At the end of the train were two diesel engines as well, and a scenic train like that made up of a few passenger cars should not need that much power. My guess is that the steam engine needs one of the diesel ones just to push it alone. 

Sure is pretty, though. Listening to it go down the valley, huffing and blowing its whistle, maybe that makes it all worthwhile.