Cast Iron & “Never”

Never and forever are neither for men.
You’ll be returning again and again. 

-Fritz Leiber, “The Circle Curse,” Swords Against Death

My wife of 25 years did something I warned ‘never’ to do: she put a piece of my cast iron through the dishwasher. This is the classic offense against Southerners’ sensibility that people from the north do after they move down here. This was a grill press rather than a skillet, but still  

Cast iron really is indestructible, though. It took some work to clean the rust and reseason it today, but it came out just fine. I shouldn’t have worried about it. 


It’s good as new, which is to say, not as good. But it’s good enough to get started rebuilding a new layer of seasoning. 

8 comments:

Thos. said...

I know that that is a "rule", but I have washed and re-seasoned any number of cast iron pans over the years.
Sometimes you'll have one that's just been so badly mistreated or neglected that the best way to fix it is to get it back to bare metal and then reseason it.
It's better not to get to that point in the first place, but it's not the end of the world, either.

douglas said...

Of course that's true, Thomas, but it's a great excuse to put up that excellent quote for sure.

Anonymous said...

Hand washing cast iron is sometimes OK, sort of. Dishwasher is a big no-no. A friend has a cast iron pan that his grandmother got back, ah, “some years ago.” I’m not sure anything would even dare think of sticking to it, it is so well seasoned.

LittleRed1

Assistant Village Idiot said...

It depends on what the "seasoning" is. It's good to get a wide variety of things worked in, but a few always taint everything after, and it's better to just start over.

No soap though. I know some people do and say it's fine, but I have never dared.

raven said...

Since you are still married, one must assume the Bowie did not go in the dishwasher......

Francis W. Porretto said...

Numerous disasters have flowered from letting the missus load the dishwasher. It's definitely the man's job.

Grim said...

She didn’t wash the Bowie. That’s both my backpacking knife (because it is very light, in spite of its size) and also my slaughter/butchering knife. It was made by a local Cherokee knife maker by stock reduction from an old sawmill blade.

Grim said...

My sister expressed that same sentiment to her husband when he complained about her not washing the dishes before loading them.