Innocent blood

From First Things:
Innocent blood is a powerful reality. It turns the wheel of history. I believe Kirk’s murder will have this effect.
The evil deed of September 10, 2025, will expose the desperation of the old and failed consensus that Kirk opposed. The consensus he hoped to turn us toward, one that restores faith, family, and flag, will triumph.

7 comments:

Grim said...

This has been the weirdest experience. I didn't know of Kirk before he was killed, so I have kind of a blank slate about who he was. More so than I can ever recall, the opinions that developed about this guy are completely oppositional.

The college professors I know -- and I know quite a few -- have been universal in their condemnation of him. Only a few have actively celebrated his death, but almost all think it was completely justified. They've used phrases like "it isn't celebrating death not to mourn the passing of a monster." They've used profane language to discuss him, and to suggest that his murder was something that he plainly had coming. They've quoted a selection (I assume often without complete context) of things he's said or allegedly said that they thought were clear incitement. And many, many of them have pointed out that Republicans seem to care about this but not about the actual innocents -- usually school shootings -- that their intransigent refusal to give up their guns is clearly the sole cause of occurring. So much hate from so many highly educated people who think of themselves as, and in some respects are, decent, educated, upright people.

Then I read the other side, and it reads like this. He was an innocent; a martyr; kind hearted; generous to his opponents in debate. He was a man of peace and reason who just wanted to bring people to understand each other and begin to work out their disputes in a peaceful way.

Richard Fernandez used to talk about how the different parts of America were somehow 'watching different movies.' But this one is completely detached from the other. It's not just that the heroes and villains are reversed; there's not even the same plot being played out on the screen.

Thomas Doubting said...

We've been there for a while, I think.

Grim said...

I suspect the intensity of the hate from the college professors has to do with the fact that his organization tended to target colleges and universities in order to challenge the beliefs that almost all professors have inculcated in their hearts and minds (if only to fit in with the tribe). So he was a special insult to them, I guess. But it's just been amazing to watch.

raven said...

Every party of totalitarians has lots of highly educated people in their ranks.
That does not imply any moral standard.
I don't know a thing about Kirk. Except that he was sitting down talking with someone and a POS blew his throat out.
This is not defensible. In any way at all.
And the people who suggest that it was, have a psychological void that may be un-fillable.
I really don't give a shit how erudite they present, or how fine their suits are or what their taste in wine is- they stink like 6 day dead in the underbrush.
What got murdered along with Mr. Kirk was moderation.
As of now, it is war footing. Finland, 1918.

When I was a kid, I had a box of .303 shells.(my brothers, he was over in VN). And firecrackers in yankeeland were verboten. But us kids found some fuse cord, and we drilled holes in the rifle rounds, for the fuse, pulled the bullets and crimped over the case end. Then we stuck a couple inches of fuse in and ran like hell, to evade the case shrapnel. The boom was awesome. But we soon realized that we had way more shells than fuze, and kept cutting them shorter and shorter. Pretty soon they were to the point of only having a 1/4" of so sticking out. It started to get sporty, because the time between lighting it, and detonation, was 1 full second. We had to light them behind a stump.
That is where we are now, politically.

We have a bunch of people, wide swathes of people, millions openly celebrating the murder of a man who dealt in ideas.
You all tell me- how do we negotiate with that? They smoked the idea of compromise, discussion, negotiation- - if there was ever a "my way or the highway" that was it.


Thomas Doubting said...

Kirk's assassination was terrible, but it fit into a pattern I thought I knew. The public support for and even rejoicing over his murder is changing how I view the Left. It is the first thing that's made me think a civil war really is possible. Not probable, mind you, just possible. Still, it's pretty alarming.

Texan99 said...

FWIW, my FB feed is running about 40-1 against the argument that Kirk "had it coming." The two sad individuals who are gamely taking the minority position haven't much to say for themselves and seem to be regarded generally as unpleasant examples of weak mind and character unfortunately present in our community. Of course, this is a rural red county, and my FB following is fairly conservative.

Texan99 said...

My following also is pretty aged.