Sea Storms and Fate

An article on the 717 siege of Constantinople raises a theme that occurs again and again in history:
Still, the Muslims’ troubles were far from over. Nature was not through with them. A terrible sea-storm is said to have all but annihilated the retreating ships, so that, of the 2,560 ships embarking back to Damascus and Alexandria, only ten remained — and of these, half were captured by the Byzantines, leaving only five to make it back to the caliphate and report the calamities that had befallen them (which may be both why the Arab chroniclers are curiously silent about the particulars of these events, and why it would be centuries before Constantinople would be similarly attacked again).

This sea-storm also led to the popular belief that divine providence had intervened on behalf of Christendom, with historians referring to August 15 as an “ecumenical date.”
How many such storms, so severe as to thrash a navy or an army traveling by sea, have convinced people of a divine hand at work? Salamis, Artemisium, Constantinople, the Spanish Armada, the kamikaze that broke up Kubla Khan's fleets...

3 comments:

Tom said...

I wonder, could a modern naval fleet be wiped out by a storm? Given advances in ship design and the ability to more-or-less predict severe weather, I tend to think it won't ever happen again, but I'm just guessing.

Eric Blair said...

Likely not, not so much because ships are better, as because storm tracking is so much better now.

douglas said...

I think Grim meant to link to this wiki on Kamikaze (Typhoon).