This year, instead of writing a commentary I think I will write an original work. I have one in mind that I have been thinking for a few years now that I ought to write. It should be an ethical and political philosophical work on the value of minding one's own business.
There is a clear universal value here: everyone would be happier if other people minded their own business more than they do, accepted the individual's own sense of what was most important to them more than they do, and attempted to impose externally valued things upon them less than they do.
However, the opposing view is endemic especially to political philosophy. Readers who have followed my commentary on Plato's Laws or Aristotle's EN -- or remarks from his Politics and Rhetoric likewise, though I haven't written commentaries on those -- know that the idea that the Wise should impose rules and structures to guide others towards virtue are at the basis of their projects. Collectivist philosophies of our own age draw generally from a chain that usually runs through Marx and Hegel back to Plato; but even many Christian thinkers, who reject at least Marxism's claim that religion is merely an opiate, generally think that institutions and laws should impose values on the people to morally guide them towards right living. Republicans generally want to ban pornography; Democrats want to ban guns, even when the guns are chiefly used for lawful purposes and to the common good; in both cases the chief objection seems to be that the things cause people to become morally worse and that we'd have a better society if we eliminated the poisons they represent. Neither of the major ethical traditions at work today, Utilitarianism nor Deontology, are interested in the question of minding one's own business; rather, they seek to shape society either to increase collective utility or morality.
Over against this massive set of traditions stands only a limited endorsement of rights like free speech and free association (both under assault) in the American tradition; or the more radical Stoic philosophers' claims that you should only attend to your own mind, and not really even your own body, since only that is under your control. Such a discipline would entail 'minding your business,' but the point wasn't that minding your business was a moral duty, rather that doing anything else was a waste of your limited time and attention.
So I think I need to write this book while power and time remains to me to do it. I doubt anyone will agree with it, but that isn't the point of philosophy. The point is to try to say something that you think is true, and if you succeed, to let other people explain their own reasons for disagreement. Philosophy is at its best when it creates problems like that for us to sharpen our minds by rubbing against.
No comments:
Post a Comment