You Can't Run a Military Without Weirdos

I am a free speech absolutist, as I generally am about basic rights: 1A or 2A or 4A, all of them all the way. However, the government is not covered by those rights; governments don't have rights, they have powers, and the powers of governments are wisely regulated. 

There's also the question of practical wisdom where government statements are concerned. 
Hegseth: No fatties, no trannies, no beardos, no weirdos, no wimps, no radicals
There was actually a good reason why the beards became a thing during the GWOT. 


Of course Pete is speaking to the regulars, not the operators. The regulars benefit from regularity; as Washington said, discipline is the soul of the army. 

You still have to make room for the weirdos, though, because they are disproportionately likely to be the one who brings back the rest. The attribution of that quote to Heraclitus is a modern fabrication; the idea is not ridiculous.
[Mad Jack] Churchill was second in command of No. 3 Commando in Operation Archery, a raid on the German garrison at Vågsøy, Norway, on 27 December 1941.  As the ramps fell on the first landing craft, Churchill and his Commando leapt forward from their position, while he was playing "March of the Cameron Men" on his bagpipes. They overran the garrison in less than ten minutes, killing or capturing all the enemy soldiers they encountered.... 
In July 1943, as commanding officer, he led No. 2 Commando from their landing site at Catania, in Sicily, with his trademark Scottish broadsword slung around his waist, a longbow and arrows around his neck and his bagpipes under his arm.

Similarly: Should you insult your core supporters?

Young white men are developing the same sort of mentality that blacks, Hispanics, gays, and others have developed. While it might not be tribal per se, it is defensive. And young white men are very aware of their status in society — namely, being the only people it’s OK to abuse, discriminate against, bully, cancel, and so on. Their level of tolerance and their sense of humor around those things is at a low ebb.
Nobody much likes having a group they belong to painted with broad-brush criticism; women don't like it, men don't like it, Boomers don't like it; I've courted some of that with my recent posts, though I trust everyone here is sophisticated enough to understand that such criticisms aren't intended as universal claims but as statistical ones. What's going on here is something different: it's electing to pretend that 'white boys named Brad' are the problem even though, statistically, they really are not. It's akin to the German posters that pretended that white [female!] Germans were feeling up black immigrants at the pool rather than otherwise. 

Just speaking the plain truth is the best use of free speech, for governments and otherwise. 

12 comments:

  1. Astonishingly awful response to the critique by the candidate; she seemed unable to grasp that people weren't complaining about the proposed policy but about the way it was being marketed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes, the objection isn’t to the policy; if she wanted to eliminate welfare entirely she would have provoked less ire.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Coming from an oblique angle, there was a post a day or so ago on Ann Althouse's blog referencing assisted dieing where a commenter noted this has probably happened since the distillation of effective but potentially lethal pain relievers but nobody made it officially sanctioned, and looked away when it happened. As you note, so long as the people who need the slack can get the slack it's not a bad thing to bring back the discipline

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's interesting to compare and contrast the Green Berets with the 75th Rangers. The former ends up being excepted from many standards in order to allow operators to operate; the latter apply even more intense versions of the standards to themselves and each other, and have a culture of running out those who don't keep up with the higher standards. Both variations seem to work.

      Delete
  4. Anonymous10:07 PM

    Well, you could run a military without weirdos, but what fun would that be?

    - Tom

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not sure that you could. Especially not with the draft; but even without it, somebody's gotta run the signal corps.

      Delete
    2. I'd say that while you need the Mad Jacks, it's important that they be recognized as exceptions, and that they earn the right to be excepted by being exceptional.

      Delete
    3. Anonymous9:25 PM

      I'll defer to Janet on that score, Grim.

      That said, I think the commie's tend to try to run their militaries w/o weirdos. I think that's one of their problems, but you didn't say "You can't run a competent military without weirdos."

      I also don't think this is what Hegseth meant by weirdos. I think he meant furries and other bizarre things we've seen in uniform lately. But, who knows? I haven't seen any clarification coming out.

      - Tom

      Delete
    4. Anonymous8:53 AM

      You can talk about us, but you can't talk without us.

      --Janet

      Delete
    5. That’s a great line.

      Delete
  5. Incidentally, decrying "boomers" for accumulating wealth AND Social Security payments is all the rage today; but as they die off, boomers will effect one of the largest wealth-transfers in history, bestowing all those (ill gotten??) gains on their children and grandchildren.

    Unless they piss us off even more.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am in no rush to obtain the wealth that my father left to my mother, his wife of nearly 50 years; may she enjoy it as long as possible.

      Delete