Pike herself wanted other options. Through her attorneys, she asked for an all-female firing squad or a hanging, perhaps with the Carruthers precedent in mind. The state apparently does not allow for those choices – a few do – although the electric chair may still have been an option. Tennessee does not allow it for recent death-penalty sentences, but it was still an option in 1996 when Pike committed her crime.Governments do not necessarily owe murderers their choice of execution methods. However, they do owe a death to them and the victims of the crime rather than an extended, painful process that ends without any finality.What's next? It might depend on whether Pike sustained brain damage in this attempt. No one is sure yet what her medical status is, and whether she remains competent to contest another warrant for execution. No governor will sign a death warrant for a prisoner who got brain damage from a previously botched execution.
If we are going to get rid of prisons, as we should, capital punishment is the obvious alternative for particularly serous crimes. It's really not difficult to kill a living being; humanity has a tremendous amount of experience, even expertise, in how this is done. There is no reason to make this hard, especially when the condemned have themselves requested a workable method.
Of all the challenges facing our governments this is the one thing I'm sure they could really do. Even Communist governments can succeed at killing people. Especially Communist governments, I suppose, but they do everything else so poorly their efficiency at this one task is remarkable. To be incompetent at killing is a chosen handicap.
Firing squad by anti-aircraft gun? Nah, probably not.
ReplyDeleteThere is precedent, though I don't recall how recent and don't know how dispositive, for a person surviving an execution attempt having the execution sentence set aside on the grounds that God wanted him/her to survive.
Given an entirely appropriate desire to execute as painlessly as possible, it seems to me that one other means would serve: take the prisoner down with ether, then suffocate him/her with pure nitrogen via a nitrogen mask closely akin to an oxygen mask. I'm not sure the ether prelude would be necessary, my understanding is that a person in a pure nitrogen atmosphere doesn't feel like he's suffocating, he just dies from the oxygen deprivation.
It also seems to me that 30 years on death row is itself cruel and inhuman, to the extent government lawyer delays played the strongly dominant role in the 30 years. Still pretty cruel if the defense lawyers' delays were dominant: there's those 30 years either way.
Regardless of any of that, it's critical that the public as well as the State understand how what should be been a straightforward lethal injection could be botched twice. Too small veins, as Pike reportedly feared; botched injection setup; drugs too old and lost lethality; attendants' efforts to inflict a measure of the same pain of which Pike had been convicted; something(s) else.
Eric Hines
I also have heard that a hanging victim who survived, if say the rope broke, would be set free on the grounds of divine intervention.
DeleteReportedly the victim in this case requested and received an all-female execution team. If we wanted to be sure of it, instead we might ask for an all-Canadian one. We would just need to tell them that she was depressed rather than a criminal.
While I don't have specifics but have heard that death penalty opponents have succeeded in blocking the use of the most effectively lethal compounds, and no doubt written the procedures, such that a non-lethal outcome is more likely.
ReplyDeleteWhat I've heard in this regard is that death penalty opponents didn't succeed in blocking the most effective directly; they did succeed in drastically reducing their availability of them by making their manufacture/sale to prisons extremely expensive with their litigation.
DeleteOf course they didn't commit a single neuron to thinking about the likely outcome of their actions--the botched execution of Pike (assuming it was a legitimate attempt), for instance.
Eric Hines
I'd have to add that failing to get the shot into her veins (as I'm hearing but not sure that's been verified) would be a strange reason to stop the procedure. Find another vein, inject more. There is no downside in this use case for giving more depressant- failure is the objective. Give her a third, fourth shot. Double the doses. Even if those also went IM eventually they'd succumb. There's something strange going on here. I'll add that my first job was in a hospital lab- Doctors were notoriously bad at drawing blood (finding the vein), and nurses seemed to be ok, but the Phlebotomists were the best. Maybe they needed a Phleb to run a line first, as maybe the nurses aren't of the same quality as in the past.
Delete