USMC: Actually, Women Won't Have To Do Pull-Ups

Back in the Grand Old Days of Commandant Amos -- you know, 2012 -- the Corps was going to do away with special tests for women. Women wouldn't have to do as many pull-ups as men to get as good a score (and promotions are based in part on PFT scores). But they would have to do at least three pull-ups to stay in the Marines.

Now, well, no.
The plan never made it off the ground, though. Data collected in 2013 found that 55 percent of female recruits couldn’t meet the minimum requirement. A study of 318 female Marines found that the women could complete 1.63 pullups on average. Roughly 20 percent of those Marines could only hit three pullups if they used their lower bodies in a[n illegal] "kipping" motion....

“I think this is a great way to implement the change as it gives an incentive to increase a score without the fear of failing the PFT," Col. Robin Gallant, II Marine Expeditionary Force’s comptroller, said of the proposal. "As women work on them to increase their score, they can be confident that they won't fail a PFT. I think this is a huge benefit and I'm glad it might become a reality."
It is a huge benefit to whom, exactly? To the Corps? Or to those women who can't meet the minimum standards that we were assured would never be lowered? I can see how it's a huge benefit to them to remove the danger of them failing just because they can't pass the test.

4 comments:

  1. Eric Blair8:12 PM

    I can't see how this is going to end well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Getting good grades is *far* more important than actually learning anything!

    :-(

    ReplyDelete
  3. raven9:36 AM

    If the men have to pick up the women's load (literally) they are going to start to resent it after a while.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ymar Sakar12:09 PM

    Some guy out of high school was doing 26 pull ups on some exercise circuit with a group I know. That was pretty hilarious to hear about. Got a slightly line backer ish build as well.

    ReplyDelete